Facebook: Less Friends = More Engagement

So I did a bit of unscientific analysis. January 7 is my birthday, and I was noticing that it seemed like I had a steady stream of friends dropping in to say “Happy Birthday” and that’s always good. But after thinking about it a day or two, I wondered how it stacked up to the previous year. There are many factors that could have influenced the numbers one way or the other, but the key factor was the total number of friends that I have on Facebook. For most of the time since I first signed up for Facebook in January of 2007 each year has seen a steady growth of friends as I reconnected with the past and reached out across the RV and travel blog worlds. But some time last year I decided to make a big change.

I unfriended half of my friend list.

I went from over 400 friends to just over 200. There were several reasons for making this decision. The primary driver for it was simply the fact that Facebook is constantly tinkering with their algorithms that determine what is shown on your news feed. If it doesn’t show up there, it is unlikely to be noticed. And the only way to re-engage is to visit every single friend’s wall on a regular basis and interact – like or comment, etc. Yet why would I do that with ex-co-workers and classmates that I haven’t seen in person in 20-30 years? If we didn’t start interacting right after we first friended each other, there’s probably a reason for that…

For me, the reasons are mostly my fault. Using my high school as an example, most of my ex-classmates still live in and around the Dallas-Fort Worth, Texas area. While I still lived there we interacted and coordinated our 30-year reunion. Once that was over, the interaction faded. In addition, my views on politics and religion have shifted drastically. I’m almost the only one of my 76 classmates who is no longer Republican or christian. And given the nature of Facebook, posts about those topics make up the vast majority of people’s activity. In the end, I hid many of them, just to keep my news feed from being full of things that irritated me.

So now I have a large chunk of my Friends who are hidden from my feed, but I kept them as friends because I thought that maybe they would see my own posts and still interact. But most of them didn’t. I’m not blaming them, we just don’t share many current interests or live in the same area any more. In other words, our connection on Facebook was one of a shared place and time, some shared memories, but not much else. The classmates who are still on my list were people who I either dated or were in band with. We were friends in high school. That gives us a bond and extra memories to work with.

So for awhile I was stuck in this limbo. Most of my Friends never interacted with me, yet I left them on my list in hopes they would see my posts, especially our travel blog posts. And then I discovered a hidden feature about Facebook: Followers.

Facebook introduced subscriptions in late 2011. It allows you to ‘follow’ someone (like a celebrity) without having to go through the Friend approval process. As long as the celebrity makes a public post, all subscribers see it. This also works with regular people, too. They now call it followers, and I have 25 people who have manually decided to follow me rather than make a Friend request. But then I made the big discovery…

If you unfriend someone, they automatically change from your Friend to a Follower!

For some reason this made me feel a lot better about cleaning up my Friend list. It doesn’t feel like I am abandoning my FB friends – I’m just changing their status a bit. So while I have 438 people who can all see my public posts, I have only 223 Friends who can see most of what I post. (I also have a smaller Friend ‘list’ I use for more sensitive matters, usually jokes or items having to do with politics or religion). 

And all of this is great, but how did it effect my engagement?

To compare, I looked at how many people wished me Happy Birthday for the last two years. On January 7, 2012, when I had approximately 400 friends, 59 of them dropped in to wish me a happy one. That works out to around 14%. On January 7, 2013 with my newly pared-down Friend list of 223 I had 49 birthday greetings, almost 22%. I find this an encouraging number, especially since we haven’t even lived in the United States for the last eleven months!

So yes, it’s unscientific and there are many other factors, but I’m very happy to have shifted a lot of Friends over to Followers. Besides, it kinda makes me feel like a celebrity with an entourage!

The Keyword Academy: A Plan, or Just a Scheme?

I recently wrote about the difficulty of online marketing if you happened to grow a conscience. On a related note, I now consider a lot of online marketing to be some form of scheme. It typically involves using the internet in some way that attempts to shortcut normal business processes. I just wrote a more detailed post on another blog about my being a closet schemer. I want to write here about why you need a plan, not a scheme, and how this relates to The Keyword Academy.

First, let me mention some major changes that have occurred recently at The Keyword Academy. For one thing, they have temporarily closed their doors to any new members. [They seem to be taking new members again - very limited number andtime!] Second, they have split Postrunner off into a separate service, with a separate fee. Your first site is free, however additional sites will cost extra: $50/month for 20 sites, $200/month for unlimited. This still looks like a pretty good deal compared to similar services. Third, they have tiered their affiliate program. You get 20% commission as a normal affiliate but 30% if you are also a member of Postrunner. Fourth, they are no longer directly connected to the Niche Refinery service. It is now separate. Fifth, the main benefits that the Keyword Academy is currently offering is their ‘eBook’ on how to make $5000/month, miscellaneous videos, the user forum and a series of emails.  Sixth, Courney Tuttle has made a splash reappearance after a couple of years of focusing elsewhere. [UPDATE: Court is now sole owner of TKA!] Seventh, the Keyword Project Manager has also been spun off as a separate service. So, a LOT of change going on over there!

From what I can tell, it seems to me that they are shifting most of their focus to Postrunner, with less emphasis on the membership forum.

So is The Keyword Academy a plan or a scheme? First, let me throw out my definitions:

Scheme

* Made for Adsense sites

* Exact Match Domains

* Article spinning

* backlink services

* Forum backlinks

* comment backlinks

* outsourced writers

* Trying these same tactics with ebooks

Plan

* Quality original content

* PPC or social links

* Purely organic backlinks

* e-commerce – dropshipping, etc.

* Selling your own products

* Writing a quality ebook

* Selling ads/links to your site based on organic traffic

* Creating and marketing to an email list

Which one of these is TKA promoting? It looks like they are doing a lot from both categories. Their PostRunner service is mainly for getting backlinks. From what I can tell, so far they have managed to stay off Google’s radar, which is quite a feat! Any service that can manage to survive the Panda and Penguin updates must be doing something right.

Of course there are a lot of other tools and services out there, and you can piece them together and roll your own if you are a do-it-yourself sort of person, but hey – why not take advantage of an inexpensive comprehensive solution?

So go check it out, and you can start off with a free ebook! Here’s the details:

How To Really Make $5000 Per Month Online

A true story of success through hard work, solid techniques, and more hard work.

by Court Tuttle

Today’s Free Download Includes:

My 26 page ebook, “How To Really Make $5000 Per Month Online” that explains in detail exactly how I created three different websites that each make more than $5000 per month.

8 step-by-step videos that walk you through the entire process of registering a domain name (a .com name) and using free, easy-to-use software to create effective, profitable websites.

Bonus video that shows exactly how I leverage 100% free methods to create lucrative, low maintenance side incomes.

A walk-through of the tools, concepts, rules, and secrets that you can use to pick winning markets to build sites around.

The make money online concepts that have allowed me to develop valuable traffic that’s 100% free and how I have leveraged that traffic into ongoing profits.

The #1 secret that allows people to make money on the internet without sacrificing their lifestyle or becoming a slave to their online business.

The exact specifics and details of how I have successfully developed easy-to-make web properties that are worth $100,000+ with hard work but little to no investment.

So – there you have it! Just click here and check it all out for free!

image

image

If You Join Triberr, I will unfollow: Here’s Why

So I was scrolling through Hootsuite today and reading some tweets and I came across one from @AuthorMEAnders that seemed interesting. Something about “the birth of beta reader extraordinaire” I assumed it was either a beta reading service startup or something like that…

No. Someone was acknowledging a best friend’s birthday, and it seemed to have nothing to do with M.E. Anders. I went back to the original tweet, and there it was.

“via Triberr”

I should have known. Unfortunately this means that I have to unfollow her. For all the details on this you can read my previous article, but the bottom line is that Triberr enables you to semi-automate or fully automate the process of retweeting. And this is what you end up with – you retweet almost everything your fellow tribe-mates tweet, and it fills up your tweet stream with lots of crap.

I need less crap.

Growing a Conscience

I have a long and sordid history with modern snake oil salesmen. They prey on my greed and impatience and I part with my money far too easily and too often. I may have developed a bit of resistance to their hypnotic gaze, but I still sometimes feel that familiar attraction. Every reformed junkie knows what this feels like. It’s like when you take Sudafed for a head cold, but later you feel that slight tingling sensation at the base of your neck, the slight sting up in your sinuses as the pseudoephedrine hydrochloride goes to work. You remember all of the pleasures of meth and none of the negatives.

The same seems to apply to the con and scam artists of the internet. Recently a paid SEO/Internet Marketing forum I am a member of had an interesting discussion about the new feature article posted over on The Verge. Someone linked to it and asked for people’s opinions. The first several responses agreed with the author while mentioning that they were uncomfortable that the author had lumped *all* internet marketers in with the true scum. But then several people chimed in to defend some of the major personalities attacked in the article! Even the original poster defended them to some extent.

I made a feeble attempt to point out what I thought was obvious, but it was to no avail and I ended my participation in that thread with a lame “we’ll just have to agree to disagree” type of post.

Today someone in that same forum linked to a recent article from Leo Dimilo on his newer Drunk On Life blog – Confessions of an Internet Marketer. It’s a great read, and it confirmed much of my recent thinking about my future direction in online marketing. It starts with a question:

Q. What’s the most dangerous thing a marketer can do?

A. Grow a Conscience

And that is the main problem I have with the hucksters mentioned in the Scamworld piece. Even those that my fellow internet marketers were defending don’t seem to me to have much of a conscience. Some of this can legitimately be seen as a grey area. After all, aren’t all voluntary transactions between consenting adults technically both legal and amoral?

As I was reading and thinking about the topic, I was reminded of a time when I myself would have defended this type of person. I understand the reasoning. You buy an overpriced, hyped product from someone, you feel the need to justify it. If said product has helped you to make some money, often that is justification enough. Just don’t develop a conscience about it and start thinking about the cycle you are in. Don’t dwell on the fact that you are purchasing a product that, for example, shows you how to make money by teaching you to how to sell their product to other people, or teaches you how to separate the naive and desperate from their money. This type of ‘circle-jerk’ cyclical Ponzi scheme of marketing is the modus operandi of most of those exposed in Scamworld.

And then I remembered her. That lady. The one I took advantage of just to line my pockets with cash.

Of course I don’t remember her name, or really even her face. That might personalize things a bit too much. But under the guise of ‘helping’ her I instead took advantage of her desperation and naivety, pocketing a wad of cash in the process.

The product line I had bought into here was Ron LeGrand’s ‘Cash Flow Generator’ which was basically a few binders and CD’s with information and forms all about making a fortune in real estate. Most of the information was outdated, but some was still relevant and worked. We went all in. I believe that by the time all was said and done, we had attended two seminars (we flew to one in Nashville), bought two or three packages of info and ‘invested’ around $9,000.

The techniques were all ‘grey-hat.’ We pushed the edges of morality and legality. And after many stops and starts, I unfortunately got a bite. I contacted a woman who was selling her home. As it turns out, she had gone through a divorce and was being drained by the mortgage payments and just wanted out. The house needed some work. By this time I had begun partnering with a couple of remodelers and used their main contractor to give me an estimate. He agreed to buy the home for a certain price.

The home owner at some point had told me what she owed on the home, and I made an offer that would give her enough room to clear maybe $1000 after fees. I used some techniques common in the sales industry when I made my offer. Specifically, I told her the amount, then I shut up. She spoke first, voicing her hopes that she would be able to make more on the house. I said something like “Yeah, I know” and nodded my head. I waited her out. Eventually, she agreed and signed my form, an assignment of contract. She assigned to me the right to the home, but I would then turn around and assign the contract to my contractor. This is what is referred to as ‘flipping’ a home.

A couple of weeks later all of the paperwork was in place and I went to the title company to sign my part. My title agent told me the funds should clear by the next day. When I went back to pick up my check I got a bit of a lecture. The title agent, a wife of one of my real estate breakfast buddies, scolded me a bit and told me it was a good thing she liked me. As it turns out, my contractor had assigned *his* contract to another investor that he knew, who in turn assigned it to yet another person. Five different parties had come in and signed, with the final person taking ownership. I didn’t care. I walked away with a check for $14,000 in my pocket.

At this point in the tale, I could (and did) tell people that my investment in Ron Legrand’s Cash Flow Generator was worth it, and that I had more than made my money back on it. His real estate investment schemes could then be seen as ‘legitimate.’ Technically true, but that didn’t stop Ron from attempting to get more money out of me. I was a bit surprised one day to get a postcard from him, telling me about a way to make even *more* money than real estate. It was easy. All you have to do is … (wait for it) …

Host a real estate seminar!

I should have seen the irony. He was telling me that he made more money by selling me a seminar package than he did by actually following the instructions in the seminar package. And the same can be said for probably 75% of all informational products out there, especially the high-dollar items.

Unfortunately the irony was lost on me, and my profitable status didn’t last long. The contractor in that deal is the same contractor I had become involved with while doing some partnership remodeling deals with a couple of other real estate investors. These guys weren’t snake oil salesmen, they were better than that — straight up old-school con men. By the time all was said and done they had caused me to deplete my meager retirement fund and any other profits I made elsewhere, max out a couple of lines of credit and eventually forced me into filing a half-million dollar Chapter 7 bankruptcy.

That karma sure is a bitch!

It was a painful learning experience, but I would like to think that I won’t have to learn it all over again. It is a major reason why I find similar types of pitch men to be distasteful. And yes, when it comes to internet marketing I would put Frank Kern, Anthony Morrisson, Mike Filsaime, John Paul Raygoza and Jeremy Johnson all in that same bucket with Ron Legrand, Carlton Sheets,  and Robert Kiyosaki and all the other real estate ‘gurus’ out there. Snake oil.

The age-old debate here often comes down to motivation. One side points out that if these people were making such good money in real estate or internet marketing, why would they need to sell a ‘system’ to others? Wouldn’t they be creating competition? The other side often points out that these people made legitimate money on their own and are now helping others as an extra stream of income, something that is smart. They also assert that there is plenty of room for competition without hurting one’s own market.

I beg to differ – most of these scammers started making money by selling their system on how to make money. Ron Legrand’s background is in working the skeeball tent at carnivals. Kiyosaki is harder to pin down, but John T. Reed wrote quite a lengthy expose on him.

So yes, as someone who has been working the system in Internet Marketing, I have a problem. My conscience is waking up, and it’s getting harder and harder to justify flirting with the edge of the grey. Coincidentally I have been working on doing something somewhat like a normal business — creating and selling my own product! For now, mainly some short memoirs to be sold on Amazon. Unlike most internet marketing products, these will be in the NON-fiction category.

——————————————————————————-

For more information on the real estate gurus like Ron Legrand, check out John T. Reed’s excellent Real Estate Guru Rating page.

More on Legrand’s recent charges brought by the SEC.

For more information on the scammers in the internet marketing arena, check out the silliness over at the Salty Droid.